Book Review of Julia Lovell's "The Opium War: Drugs, Dreams and the Making of China"
http://www.cefc.com.hk/pccpa.php?aid=2856
To the reader's delight, Lovell has excellently produced a clear, agreeable, and lively account. Some lengthy passages could have been shortened, especially descriptions of the horrors of different military operations, as well as discussions of the appalling hacks pushing the Yellow Peril thesis (pp. 274-291). It is regrettable that Lovell seems to be unaware (but then again, unfortunately, so is a near totality of opium historians) that the routinely reproduced photographs of opium smokers in the late Qing are just studio jobs meant to fuel a flourishing picture postcard industry presenting a rather spurious exoticism. It is thus futile to theorise as she does over the degree of addiction and even more over the feelings of "smokers" from the time the cliché caught on (p. 17).
Comments
There are no comments yet.